The health care surcharge is optional — the reporting once you use it is not
San Francisco's Health Care Security Ordinance (HCSO) requires covered employers to spend a minimum amount per hour on health care for covered employees. The ordinance itself, per the city's own administrative guidance published through the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE), does not require or prohibit an employer from adding a surcharge to customer checks to help cover that cost — that choice, often labeled "SF Mandates," "Healthy SF surcharge" or similar on a receipt, is entirely the employer's. What is not optional is what follows once an employer chooses that path: a covered employer that imposes such a surcharge must report to OLSE, annually, both the amount collected through the surcharge and the amount actually spent on covered employees' health care.
The consequence that makes this a real compliance obligation rather than a pricing footnote: if the surcharge collected in a year exceeds what the employer spent on covered employees' health care, the administrative guidance requires the employer to irrevocably spend that excess on health care for those employees rather than retain it as ordinary revenue. A business that funds its HCSO obligation purely through higher menu prices, with no separate line item, does not take on this specific reporting and true-up duty — it is a consequence of the surcharge mechanism itself, not of the underlying health-spending requirement.
Where this actually bites a business
The practical failure mode is a restaurant that adds the surcharge line because a competitor does, treats the collected amount as general revenue rather than tracking it against actual health spending, and only discovers the annual OLSE reporting requirement — or the true-up obligation on a surplus — well after the money has already been spent elsewhere. Multi-location operators who use a surcharge in some San Francisco locations but not others need separate tracking for each, since the reporting duty attaches to the specific location that imposes the charge.